Psychological safety is not about being nice


​

Psychological safety is not about being nice

It is about whether people speak up when it matters

Dear Reader

Psychological safety is one of the most talked about leadership concepts.

And one of the most misunderstood.

I spent significant time working on this across an organisation.

It was not broken. But it was inconsistent.

So we focused on what was not being said.

The avoided conversations.
The issues sitting just below the surface.
​The “stinky fish” no one wanted to raise 🐟

And when people did speak up, we acted.

That is where it starts.

What psychological safety is not

It is not:

  • Being nice
  • Avoiding tension
  • Agreement at all costs
  • “Anything goes”
  • Protecting people from challenge
  • Lowering standards
  • Making meetings comfortable
  • Avoiding difficult conversations

You can have all of the above and still have low psychological safety.

Because people are still holding back.

What it actually is

Psychological safety is simple.

It is whether people speak up when it matters.

  • Calling out something that feels off
  • Challenging an idea, including your leader’s
  • Admitting a mistake early
  • Saying “I don’t know”
  • Raising a risk before it becomes an issue

And it only works if it sits alongside:

High standards. High accountability.

The best teams are not comfortable.

They are candid, respectful, and performance-oriented.

Where leaders get tested

Most leaders believe they are open to challenge.

The real test is what happens next.

  • When someone disagrees with you
  • When a mistake is raised
  • When a risk is surfaced early

Do you lean in or shut it down?

Do you explore or defend?

Do people feel heard, or do they learn to stay quiet next time?

Psychological safety is built or broken in those moments.

A simple test

Ask yourself:

  • Do people challenge you in the room, or after the meeting?
  • Are issues raised early, or when it is too late?
  • Do people say “I don’t know”, or default to confidence?

Final thought

Psychological safety is not about making things easier.

It is about making it possible to say the things that matter.

But it is not easy and it takes time to get there and stay there.

Warmly,

​
​Liz​
​Strategic Advisor | Former CEO | Founder, Volante

Based in Kenya, available globally

Volante Consulting Kenya

Read more from Volante Consulting Kenya

Leaders don't have to have all the answers On the leader we think we should be, the value of thinking space, and why leadership can still be lonely Dear Reader, I recently came across a quote that has stayed with me: “Your leadership style is the projection of the movie you are playing in your head.” I thought: wow. And then I started wondering what movie was playing in my head when I first became a CEO. I think, for quite a long time, it was some version of fake it till you make it. Possibly...

What are we changing, and what are we losing? Some reflections on AI, early career learning and what we are really looking for when we hire leaders. Dear Reader, I was talking with someone recently about the start of my career, which was, slightly alarmingly, more than 30 years ago. I was on a graduate scheme with a multinational food manufacturer. One of my first jobs was dealing with customer complaints. People would sometimes send the actual product back, and I had to work out what had...

We may be making hiring harder than it needs to be Better hiring isn't about eliminating risk. It is about getting better evidence and learning from the decisions we make. Dear Reader, Last week, I wrote about some of the hardest people decisions CEOs face once someone is already in the organisation. This week, I want to look at what happens before they get there. Hiring is one of the hardest parts of leadership. It is also something I think many organisations make more complicated than it...