Trust, control and the temptation to rescue


​

Trust, control and the temptation to rescue

The leadership tensions no one really prepares you for

Dear Reader

One of the biggest surprises for me in leadership was realising how many tensions sit beneath the surface of what we often call β€œgood leadership.”

Not obvious right or wrong answers.

Tensions.

Over the past few weeks, I have been reflecting on two I see repeatedly in CEOs and leadership teams and honestly, in myself too:

πŸ” How much visibility is helpful before it becomes control?

πŸ›Ÿ When does stepping in to help quietly become rescuing?


β€œTrust but verify”

I recently heard an entrepreneur say:

β€œI trust my team. But I also verify.”

At first, it made me uncomfortable.

Because verification can sound like mistrust.

But it reminded me of something much earlier in my career when I was leading a large product team for a major retailer.

Every so often, the CEO would become deeply involved in one seemingly tiny issue:

Gravy granules.

Customer complaints had increased after ingredient changes years earlier, and he would personally review the issue, ask detailed questions and attend taste tests.

At the time, I remember thinking:

Surely he has more important things to focus on?

What I later realised was this:

He was not really testing the gravy granules.

He was testing the system.

Could we detect declining quality?
Could complaints escalate appropriately?
Were standards slipping quietly?
Could leadership trust the information flowing upwards?

One product had become a proxy for whether the wider organisation was functioning properly.

That experience fundamentally changed how I think about dashboards, visibility and leadership oversight.

Not because leaders should micromanage.

But because strong leaders often need enough visibility to trust intelligently.


The hero leader trap

Another leadership tension I see repeatedly:

Stepping in too quickly.

I know this one personally because I used to do it constantly.

The team was exhausted.
Pressure was high.

So I would:
β€’ Finalise the paper
β€’ Take over the workshop
β€’ Do the late night revisions
β€’ Step into difficult meetings

Partly from care.

Partly because I thought:

β€œI can do this faster.”

And if I am honest, there was probably some martyr leadership in there too.

β€œI do not want the team working late, I will just do it myself.”

The problem is:

What feels supportive in the short term can quietly create dependency in the long term.

Over time:
β€’ Teams escalate instead of thinking
β€’ Ownership weakens
β€’ Leaders become bottlenecks
β€’ Organisations rely on heroic leadership instead of strong systems

At the same time, I have also seen leaders overcorrect:
coaching endlessly without enough clarity or modelling.

At one point, I remember quoting the old medical mantra:

β€œSee one. Do one. Teach one.”

Sometimes leaders doing the work is itself a teaching moment.

Not rescuing permanently.

But modelling:
β€’ How to think
β€’ How to prioritise
β€’ What good looks like
β€’ How decisions get made under pressure

Then moving back into coaching mode.

A few things I believe more strongly now

β€’ Trust and accountability are not opposites
β€’ Visibility matters
β€’ Coaching matters
β€’ Clear standards matter
β€’ Leaders stepping in occasionally is not failure
β€’ But rescuing teams continuously usually is

And perhaps most importantly:

High performing teams are not built in a quarter.

They are built through repetition, clarity, feedback, prioritisation and trust over time.

Usually much longer than leaders expect.

πŸ‘‰ What leadership tension have you found hardest to navigate?

Warmly,

​
​Liz​
​Strategic Advisor | Former CEO | Founder, Volante

Based in Kenya, available globally

​
​Unsubscribe Β· Preferences​

Volante Consulting Kenya

Read more from Volante Consulting Kenya

Leaders don't have to have all the answers On the leader we think we should be, the value of thinking space, and why leadership can still be lonely Dear Reader, I recently came across a quote that has stayed with me: β€œYour leadership style is the projection of the movie you are playing in your head.” I thought: wow. And then I started wondering what movie was playing in my head when I first became a CEO. I think, for quite a long time, it was some version of fake it till you make it. Possibly...

What are we changing, and what are we losing? Some reflections on AI, early career learning and what we are really looking for when we hire leaders. Dear Reader, I was talking with someone recently about the start of my career, which was, slightly alarmingly, more than 30 years ago. I was on a graduate scheme with a multinational food manufacturer. One of my first jobs was dealing with customer complaints. People would sometimes send the actual product back, and I had to work out what had...

We may be making hiring harder than it needs to be Better hiring isn't about eliminating risk. It is about getting better evidence and learning from the decisions we make. Dear Reader, Last week, I wrote about some of the hardest people decisions CEOs face once someone is already in the organisation. This week, I want to look at what happens before they get there. Hiring is one of the hardest parts of leadership. It is also something I think many organisations make more complicated than it...